I’m new to BW (just started reading BWC when I heard BWG had come out), so please correct me if I’m wrong here. From reading the teaser PDF, BWG seems to do a lot of good things for the game. But, there seems to be some major problems that make the product mostly worthless to new players:
-
From what I’ve heard from Luke’s interview et al. is that there are some significant mechanical changes that are incompatible with older BW supplements.
-
BW supplements include material that most other RPGs would include in core rulebooks (e.g. magic system, monsters, and adventure generation material - did I just give away my gaming background there?)
-
Luke seems to be disinterested in producing BWG versions of these products.
-
Even if the BWG community tinkered around and found suitable BWG errata for the BWR supplements, most are out-of-print.
[Edit: I just refreshed the store page and saw that Magic Burner and Adventure Burner were re-posted, so that takes a bit of wind out of my sails, but I would still like to see things like Blossoms there too.] -
There are no PDF versions of these products available for purchase. (I find these much more useful since you can edit in errata and store them on a tablet. Plus, you don’t need to worry about something being out-of-print.)
I just can’t get over the feeling that while BWG is a quality product (certainly worth the $25 cover price), it’s an abandoned, half-finished system that would require too much work to get ready to handle a full-scale fantasy campaign.