DoW: Rebuttal vs. Rebuttal

The chart on page 394 says that the Rebuttal is not a test. Don’t we both just divvy up our dice into attack and defense and roll 'em?

What happens when a Rebuttal scripts against a Rebuttal?

I think rebuttal vs rebuttal is a bit like counterstrike vs counterstrike. Each side is waiting for the other to make a point (or strike) so that they can rebut it (or strike back)

Correct. No test. Roleplay and move.