Hi! I’ve been arguing with some BW players on another forum about properties and resources.
We were talking about a noble having a small fortress, manor, etc. In the case of that noble PC giving (as a gift) a friend (other PC) a sword, horse, finery, etc., should he roll resources? Some argue that, in a small fortress, there’s surely an arsenal with weapons you can use for your own needs, so taking one and lending it shouldn’t require a roll.
I say we can let a resources roll determine that, establish the knight has many weapons in his arsenal and then roll for the retroactive purchase to see if he was taxed for that. Also, I think the clarification in the CharBu (revised), p.169 ("[the property] …does not provide the character with other free purchases form the Resources list") is relevant: you don`t get a free horse from your manor, free weapons from your castle or free finery from your palace, so I would ask for resources rolls to get that stuff. The wealth of the lord and his ease of acquiring such cheap stuff are already represented in his (surely) high resources.
Other questions:
-Is it kosher to use resources in some cases to declar purchases the character has done in the past? A lord wants to give his friends weapons, so he declares he’s got an arsenal full of them. There’s no hurry in time and the castle is nearby a city where he could have acquire them. Could an Ob4 resources roll be made to retroactively determine how was he taxed during that acquisition? It’d be similar to a circles or wise test.
-Can you give some examples of “Say yes” applied to resources? I imagine it’s fairly common for drinking on a tabern or staying at an inn (covered by LM), but a say yes applied to getting meaningfull stuff like finery, weapons or mount?
-Some argued that giving a weapon for a lord (of a fortress) is covered in his lifestyle maintenance. Is it? Are there any guidelines to set what’s covered by LM and what isn’t?