Severity of Twists, and Obstacle Cascade

I’ve been thinking about twists, and I suppose the art of the adventure phase as GM. The balance of twists vs conditions, and the severity of twists.

Pg.35 of Scholars guide makes it clear twists should introduce new obstacles, and we should never roll twice for the same obstacle.

So bearing that in mind, I’m roughly sort twists into abstract categories, based on severity in terms of number and immediacy of obstacles.

In approx order of number and immediacy of extra obstacles (using examples from the dread crypt in scholar’s guide):

  1. No redo twists. The obstacle is no more and cannot be reattempted, but there is no new obstacle. E.g. Pg.235 PCs fail to read some runes, lightning destroys them.
  2. Lost / damaged gear . The new obstacle is potentially fixing / purchasing the equipment down the line. E.g. Pg.237, losing gear (backpack) while trying to escape through a narrow tunnel.
  3. Ongoing non-condition condition. The obstacle is some ongoing detriment, plus needing to ‘cure’ the condition later. E.g. Pg.240 failed ritual leading to burning brand reducing precedence etc.
  4. New obstacle, previous obstacle resolved. PCs move past a previous obstacle, but are presented with a new one. E.g. Pg.244 spear trap pins a PC, the trap is no longer an issue, but the PCs need to free their friend. A lot of single activationt traps would fit in here (like the sleeping powder).
  5. New obstacle, previous removed. I see this as slightly different to 4. The PCs want to acheive something, fail to acheive it, and get a new obstacle. I’m not sure if this is intended, but I would put pg.243 scavenging ritual materials in here. Tomb guardian’s attack, which is the new obstacle, but the PCs don’t get the material and can’t re-attempt (perhaps there isn’t enough / it’s scattered in the fight).
  6. New obstacle, previous obstacle altered. The nature of the obstacle changes, and a new obstacle is presented. They must resolve the new obstacle before going back to the altered one. I can’t find an example in the dread crypt, so perhaps I am wrong here. My example would be the PCs want to pick a locked door, they fail, the lock is unpickable / they damage the mechanism, and they’re caught by something / someone. They must deal with the something before attempting to bypass the door by other means.

Am I correct on 5? Or should the PC’s get the ritual material? I’d put pg.240 ‘assessing the chamber of ablutions’ in this catergory also, they fail to asess the purpose and now have to deal with the corpse candles.

Is 6 valid? Or is it suggested to avoid this in torchbearer?

Have I missed anything?

In between 5 and 6 could be new obstacle + damaged gear (or similar), but again, should that be avoided?

Obviously some obstacles are more complicated than others and run more risk of leading to further tests. I’m trying to consider the immediate aftermath.

Lots of great questions.

First, I’ll just say that “context” is the answer to most of your questions, but not only that, but the key to understanding obstacle-to-obstacle. We informally call linking twists ‘chaining’, and there is an art to it to get the balance just right. I believe you are on the right track!

I think the categories are useful, but I would separate the “structure” of a twist from its fictional severity. There is no rule that twists must be balanced against conditions, but the whole game is fiction first, meaning that the complication should arise from the situation.

I would not pull punches on twists, because those are some of the most memorable moments. For example, once I turned a magician’s feet into rocks, thinking that he would want to get rid of this curse, but the player loved it and kept them for the whole campaign. It was very memorable. Not every twist has to rise to this occasion, but the point is twists add a lot to the game so no one should dread them.

The important parts are:

  • With a twist, the original task is not automatically accomplished.
  • The same test cannot be made twice for the same obstacle.
  • Either the original obstacle has been bypassed, or it remains, and the characters must find another way around it, using another ability or skill against a different obstacle.

1. No redo
I would call your no-redo twists “the original avenue is closed” rather than “there is no new obstacle.” The runes are destroyed, but now they need to find some other source of information.

This sometimes segues to what we informally call “twists down the line.” These are deferred twists that you foreshadow in the moment, but the immediate impact is not apparent. For example, “you hear a rumbling back by the entrance.” (The earthquake caused the entrance to collapse). They discover this later.

Above all else, you want to avoid the “you fail and cannot try again” type of closed ending that a lot of other games have, meaning, it is not like you attack and miss and nothing happens. Something new always has to happen or the situation changes.

2. Lost or damaged gear
Gear twists are great because it works with the pressures of the grind. If you have a backpack full of torches, the player can be confident they will not be in the darkness. But all of a sudden, if the whole backpack is lost (because they previously left it behind and now the twist removes it), then all that lost gear means they have to decide to try and get it back or go on without it.

The gear loss might create an immediate problem, such as losing a light source, or a later problem, such as needing to replace a backpack in town.

3. Ongoing non-condition consequences
These are persistent twists or curses. The burning brand and the curse from the altar are good examples. They create an ongoing fictional and mechanical problem, usually with a specified means of removing it. The important thing is that the effect is concrete and consequential rather than an improvised substitute for one of the actual conditions.

4. New obstacle, previous obstacle resolved
Valid and very common. The spear trap example works well this way. This is where you can start to chain twists together. For example, they fall down the pit, they are buried under rocks and need to get out but fail, and in the next attempt to get out the rope breaks, etc.

5. New obstacle, original objective not achieved

Yes, this can work.

The twist rule only requires the introduction of a new challenge. Therefore, the characters do not automatically get the ritual materials after failing the Scavenger test.

The adventure only says that 1d3+2 tomb guardians arrive to investigate the disturbance. It does not specify whether the incense has already been collected. They can’t bypass the original obstacle anymore in the same way, so the players have to figure something else out. The pressure is mounting and the tension increasing.

The same applies to the Chamber of Ablutions. The suggested twist merely introduces the extinguished lights and corpse candles. Therefore, learning the chamber’s purpose is not guaranteed under the twist result. The GM may reveal it, with the corpse candles representing deeper trouble, or may leave the purpose unknown and require the characters to learn it another way.

6. New obstacle, previous obstacle altered

The key here is the “Fun Once” precedent.

After failing a lock-picking Criminal test and dealing with the patrol, the characters cannot attempt the same lock-picking test again. They must bypass the door by another method, such as kicking it down (health test) or blowing it up (sapper test).

There is also a slight variation that gets into the nuance. Sometimes a test is required because of timing and pressure. If you had all the time in the world to pick a lock, most people could do so (after years of eventual attempts). But you can introduce a twist and then once it is clear, just don’t call for another test because the situation has changed and the pressure is gone. Think of this as an interruption. You pick the lock and fail, monsters show up, you deal with those, and now the lock is no longer an obstacle because there is no danger because you’ve cleared the guards.

Combination
As far as combining a new obstacle with damaged gear, this is allowed if it is one coherent twist rather than two unrelated punishments attached to one failure. Things like a collapsed bridge not only close off your exit but move you to another area. This is really the same consequence of the collapsed bridge, but there are multiple, related effects. A strong twist can have several fictional effects while still representing one clear change in the situation. It stands to reason that if you are on a bridge that falls, lots happens. What is not legit though is adding Injured on top of those twists. You can’t mix conditions and twists even though you would think falling off a bridge would hurt. If the injury is the thing, give a condition and move on.

What is missing and worth mentioning is one of the best twists: “you get what you asked, but it’s not what you wanted.” These are deferred twists. For example, you are trying to make it back to camp, fail your Pathfinder, so hold on, you find your way there, but now there are orcs in your camp. There is a new complication because what you really wanted was a safe camp, but now your camp is ruined. The rules say: “Twists can also be played so that the character appears to have succeeded at their task, but in truth they’ve just waded deeper into trouble.”

1 Like

This is the example for the Fun Once rule on page 35 of the Scholar’s Guide. They fail to pick a lock, a patrol shows up, and they’ve jammed the lock. If they drive off the patrol, they’ll have to bash down the door to get through it – which sounds like a Health test to me.

1 Like

Thanks for the considered response! I just ran the third session of a new campaign. I’ve ran a lot of burning wheel, but this is maybe my sixth session of torchbearer. So still getting my head around it.

I get this, twists and conditions can vary in severity, and should be fiction first. Then the art is presenting a fiction which allows for failure conditions to put the players under the correct severity of pressure. That balance is the skill I’m now trying to learn.

This is an interesting dimension to any non-immdiate twist, which would also include “twists down the line.”. Is it something the adventurers MUST deal with before going back to town (like a tunnel collapse behind them), is it something that might mean they should go back to town (like running out of torches), or is it something not so pressing but should be dealt with in time (like a damaged backpack if they’re not at capacity).

Can also be failing forward, which is nice. You’re pushing the grind forward, but not necessarily taking anything from the players. Though you can end the chain with a condition, gear twist, etc.

This does feel a little like saying no in this instance, which may be fine for this obstacle, the players don’t need to discover everything. I say this because they likely won’t come up with another method to figure out the purpose of the chamber. I think I overthink this sometimes, worry about not revealing things, which is maybe something to decide before the session, what info if ‘essential’ vs what is okay to miss.

Yeah this is essentially 4, you get the new obstacle, but once that’s dealt with the initial obstacle is resolved (no new test you have enough time to just do it).

Ahhh this is a useful way to think about it. I understand no twist plus condition (though you could be trying to grab something, health test, then a condition).

I’d say this is under 4. In your example, getting back to camp is resolved, but the new obstacle is the orcs. I’m in agreement though, I like this kind of twist, maybe from playing so much BW.

Thanks for this reference! Though to me there is some tension here with Koch’s “Combination” twist. He says “this is allowed if it is one coherent twist rather than two unrelated punishments attached to one failure.” and “A strong twist can have several fictional effects while still representing one clear change in the situation.”. The patrol showing up and the lock getting jammed seem like two separate punishments, the lock getting jammed doesn’t cause the patrol to show up, and the patrol showing up doesn’t cause the lock to jam. I suppose you could try weave them together a little more, the jamming lock makes a sound and something comes to investigate. I also suppose this can just be a severe twist that is obviously a severe twist to the players.

Thanks again! Very helpful to me developing my Torchbearer GM skills.

I’m just going by the rules, which are pretty open-ended about what a twist is. @koch has great advice, but I don’t think he was speaking authoritatively.

As for the example, ignore the Twist being applied for a moment. There is a rule on the page I referenced called Fun Once. The rule goes like this: You can’t have the players test the same skill or ability to overcome an obstacle more than once; either the obstacle is overcome by the first test, or the players have to find a different approach.

Bevause the players have to find a different approach, the GM would do well to frame the results in a way that makes progressing by the same means impossible.

Whatever the twist would have been, the players testing criminal again to pick the lock is afainst the rules. So, in this case, the GM wisely frames that approach to be clearly untennable: They’ve jammed the lock and so will have to bash the door down.

This is straight-forward, rules-as-written procedure: Failed Test → Twist → Obstacle Still Stands → to Fun Once.

Glad to help.

Good conversation that I’d like to add some more nuance.

Just to clarify…

My response to the combination twist was to answer the broader question of whether a twist can have multiple effects as the “situation changes.”

I want to add a key piece missing from the conversation that is the glue:

The GM is describing the environment, the situation, and the problem (before we get to the Obstacle). It is all related, and we can’t really separate them too much. I often liken it to playing ping-pong, where the GM is bouncing the ball back, and the player returns it, and it goes back and forth until we get blocked. This is all vital to understand how twists play into the whole cycle.

But I believe the current question is whether these effects have to be strictly coherent.

Technically, it is a GM judgment call. The game mandates that a twist has to make sense in the established fiction, but, otherwise, no one but the GM can answer the appropriateness for any one given situation in that world.

However, I believe it is very clear that the rulebook instructs us to play where GMs are constantly updating the situation as per Describe to Live. This means that there is a new development in the fiction, which may naturally produce several related effects, even though to the players they may seem unrelated. Again, this is GM judgment and not fiat.

I would distinguish authority from arbitrariness.

The GM’s choice is not presented as unconstrained fiat. The rules tell the GM to make judgment calls that ‘fit the scenario,’ to ‘rely on common sense,’ and to ‘integrate the game’s mechanisms into the fictional world.’

So, yes, GMs are given lots of freedom to craft a twist, but my main point is that twists are adjudicated through GM judgment and integrated into the fictional situation.

SG p. 213

Secondarily, the game master’s judgment is relied upon to integrate the Torchbearer mechanisms into their world.

SG p. 36

The game master describes the resulting scene. How does the character foul up and get tied in knots? How do they barely succeed? What unforeseen obstacle crops up and disrupts their efforts.

SG p. 213

Play proceeds as the game master describes the scene and the action occurring in it, to which the players respond by describing their characters’ actions as they interact with the scene. The game master then replies with how the environment and the supporting cast react to the characters’ actions.

SG p. 213

Making judgment calls on how to apply the rules and even how to bridge two systems so that they fit the scenario is an important part of being a game master.

SG p. 213

Guide with a light (but firm hand), rely on common sense and shape the action so it challenges the characters’ beliefs, goals, instincts and creeds.

DH p. 20

When you roll, the result will set up a new description of your situation, either improved or worsened by the result of your test.

SG p. 217

When you introduce a twist, jam a new obstacle into the players’ path.

An example of a twist that goes against this spirit of the game would be something like, you cross the bridge, you fail the test, the bridge collapses and now this random merchant back in town hates you. This comes out of nowhere and violates the integration of the fiction. However, if the situation were to change, we could integrate these two effects to make them cohesive by establishing the fiction differently. For example, the merchant has hired you to protect the bridge, your test fails, your bumbling efforts cause it to collapse, and now the merchant hates you.

My bridge example makes all that pretty clear. If a bridge collapses while you are on it, that one event might both cut off your retreat and dump you into a different area. Those are multiple consequences, but they all flow from the same fictional development. But again, more importantly, the situation has changed. That is the key, and that is the mandate. We are moved toward the next immediate obstacle (whatever is in that next area).

The example in the book of the patrol arriving and the lock jamming also works because the jammed lock is part of the updated fictional situation after the failed test. The patrol arriving is the new obstacle, while the lock remains but can no longer be approached in the same way under Fun Once. The important point is not that those two effects must be causally linked to each other, but that together they make sense as the GM’s new description of the situation following the failed attempt. Thus, cohesive. Thus, integrated. Thus, not arbitrary.