One of my players called me out for inconsistency in the Obs I was calling for on his attempts to Persuade NPCs. He was right; I’d been low-balling them in the early days and now that he’s sporting a Persuasion B5, I (without really realizing it) stopped holding back. (Compounding the matter was the fact that the stakes had risen enormously: a couple of recent Persuasion failures where the player was badgering his adoptive city’s ruler began to threaten his long-cultivated place in society as a celebrated hero.)
Inconsistency is a problem, but in trying to figure out my own policy has made me realize I’m not fully happy with the Ob=Will policy. In another thread (emphasis mine):
I think it’s Chris Chinn’s advice that good NPCs either want to help, hinder, or use the PCs - so this seems to me to be more properly the province of the GM. This is one area where I’m going to try harder.
But how would a player go about maneuvering things into a versus test? I’m honestly not sure, would love to see some examples.
[ul]
[li]Does the PC offer a deal, essentially proposing an NPC intent, in character?[/li][li]The player suggests a possible intent for the NPC to the GM, out of character?[/li][li]Player just asks the GM for a versus test or Duel of Wits, even though the NPC doesn’t have a intent?[/li][/ul]For those cases where the GM just doesn’t have an NPC use for the player (e.g. as might be true for someone the PC just circled up), it seems to me that RAW offers two choices, “Say Yes”, or “Ob 4”. I don’t see anything wrong with offering lower (even substantially lower) obstacles in cases when the NPC is predisposed to agree with the player.
For example, in Monday’s game, Bauer has his character Siggar circle up Adofo, a monk archivist (who has become the de facto abbot). Siggar wants Adofo to do some research for him - Adofo is normally keen to help and thinks highly of Siggar, but is increasingly busy, and I introduced a useful bit of color relating to his project. This was just foreshadowing, though, not something I wanted Siggar dragged into via compromise. (We’re on session 25 of the arc and I’m really trying to keep time-absorbent tangents to a minimum.) Why not offer Ob 2 or 3 (“Okay, I’ll help.”), instead of Ob 5?